This blog has been a way to interact with some of you around "subjects" that Aristotle has taught too many of us in the West, even today, to disparage: females, rhetoric, and translation. Much recovery yet to do.
Monday, February 4, 2008
The Resounding Bible (Women)
(What you may hear is not just academic. This time, it’s not rhetoric retold. It’s not voice lessons. It’s not traces of a stream. It’s not re-readings read aloud. It’s not dancing. It’s not meditations. It’s not even creative suffering.
No, those really are very very very important conversations around scholarship using feminist methods. Each hyperlink above here is to revolutionary works of Ph.D.s who refuse to be silenced. It’s their work that gives each one of us all, if we have ears to hear, more complete histories of classical rhetoric; and more complete ways of composing and writing; and more representative accounts of literacy; and wiser philosophy; and more profound lessons from literature; and more loving practices in politics; and even deeper relationships with God in Jewish and Christian theology.
But now you may be hearing something else very very very important from someone else).
Still listening? What you may be hearing is what a strong man heard as he listened to and really learned from a woman, a poor foreign refugee, a vulnerable grieving widow no less. I’m talking about the man of the Bible named Boaz, and the woman Ruth, one of the great great great grandmothers of one of the parents of the Joshua also known as Jesus.
Still listening? What you may hear is Carolyn Custis James talking about the Book of Ruth and translations of words.
Custis James is speaking up and speaking out. And so is Suzanne McCarthy.
It’s not only the interpretation of the words translated that’s important. It’s not just that some Bible words have been incompletely translated so that the translation keeps males over females and keeps men from learning from women and keeps half of humanity silencing the other half.
No, it’s also how we all go about translation. The question is whether humility and ambiguity in our human languages and our translation of them allows us all to communicate completely.
Custis James and McCarthy are asking about traditional overly-simplistic translations of these Bible words:
The Hebrew word transliterated “hesed”
The Hebrew word transliterated “ezer” and the phrase “ezer kenegdo”
The Greek word for “submission” transliterated “hupotasso”
The Greek word transliterated “anthropos”
The Greek word transliterated “adelphos”
The Greek word transliterated “kephale”
The Greek word transliterated “authentew”
The Greek work transliterated “boethos”
McCarthy is also asking about “humility and ambiguity” in the translating method.
Custis James likewise is questioning whether the proud traditional way of translating the Bible hasn’t worked against both men and women. She speaks of more complete ways of hearing the history of Ruth, and writes on the need to go around the “false dichotomy between Marys and Marthas” in the histories of Jesus.
(Custis James and McCarthy have gotten me asking these questions. I invite you to ask this with me:
Why are the stories of men and women of the Bible already in translation to begin with? Isn’t it likely that Boaz had to translate what Ruth said, if not because they spoke different languages, rather also because their male and female discourse generally is different? And why does Mary’s son come to us in stories, narratives written not in the languages spoken by Mary or this man, but in the Greek written down by his students? And why does this Jesus tell parables and speak in hyperbole and change nature by miracles when there is belief—acts that require you and me now to translate? But what if we don’t have ears to hear? What if we are arrogant? What if we presume only these two options: that either [A] there are incorrect interpretations or [B] there’s only the single interpretation? What if we’re not suspicious that the single interpretation that I see is the only one I really want because it keeps me above some other people? What if we’re not open to the possibility that [C] God enjoys diversity in his image, in his word? What if we refuse to see that Greek men who silenced women as inferiors also invented the very “either / or” logic that would destroy ambiguity and would enable great hubris? Why should any Bible translator ignore how translators of other Hebrew and Greek texts get at multiple meanings? Why should any translator of the Bible consistently insist always and only on reducing the meaning of a set of terms in Greek or in Hebrew to the single meaning that makes women shut up?
Custis James and McCarthy are also living testimonies to this:
In contrast to Boaz, Jewish and Christian men through the ages--and too often their submissive women who they would silence--have far too often and far too arrogantly refused to listen and learn.
Are you shocked to know this is still going on today? In contrast to the resounding Bible and to the resounding women of the Bible then and now, there are male pastors like this one. He blogs in hopes to keep James quiet, and he actually silences McCarthy from the comments on his blog: as if to protect himself, he identifies her as a “rebel,” calls for her “repentance,” and adds things like this: “I believe I better silence you so the blood of the sheep is not on my watch and hands.” Then to you and me he speaks from his bully pulpit: “To those watching: Please do not be scandalized that I have silenced Ms. McCarthy. Scripture is loaded with similar cases of men exercising authority by binding what should be bound, using the keys of the Kingdom Jesus delegated to the officers of His Church.” And so at risk for this man is this one translation and this one method of translation of the Bible: the “plain meaning of Scripture that Adam was created first, and then Eve; that it was not Adam, but Eve who was deceived; and that this means--according to God, the Father Almighty--that woman is not to teach or exercise authority over man.”)
If you have ears to hear, as Boaz does to hear Ruth, Listen.
Friday, February 1, 2008
Pike's Pickles
I’m not a black woman, and neither is Kenneth L. Pike. (We’re Euro-American men). His theory (as methodology) is not WOWOLFOL either, although it really is afrafeminism dressed up a little bit differently. (WOWOLFOL is Pike’s little joke that he ends one of the prefaces of one of his books with, and what I’ll end this post with. But now I’ll explain afrafeminism and Pike’s methods and then get to a few of Pike's pickles).
Some of them are these:
There was the disagreement Pike had with anthropologist Marvin Harris, who used “emic and etic all wrong.” A bit later, Pike agreed to the now famous public debate with Harris on the issue. (I never told Pike, but I always thought the more interesting disagreement was the one of Claude Levi-Strauss, who thought that Pike should have used “etic” for “emic” and vice versa, and then Gudrun and Lars H. Ekstrand came along and substantiated the Levi-Straussian claim with ancient Greek uses of the suffixes that Pike derives his terms from. Anyway, I never told Pike that I actually kind of liked Harris’s uses of “emic” and “etic”; so I’ll tell you now that I really love that the words have been found in scores of disciplines in a plethora of languages by various researchers, practitioners, and teachers.) The difficult thing for Pike here is that he wants subjectivity but is tempted to pure objectivity. (Some reading this may be tempted to think that Pike gave in, to pure abstraction for his meaning and not to Harris. But you may want to read more of what Pike says in all of this before making a final judgment. Pike never, as far as I can tell, ever backed off from his conviction that person is above logic, and that the observing person changes both the person himself or herself and the observed by their observation).
There was the disagreement Pike had with postmodernists and particularly their deconstructionism. Some poetry he authored rightly fought for author’s rights. And he defended his friends whose work was the victim of deconstruction. The difficult thing for Pike is that he wants to put person above the logic on which modernism is based, and his method would look very much like postmodernism if it weren’t, like afrafeminism, based on the subjective perspectives of humans who live in a body. In other words, postmodernism and especially deconstruction for Pike descended into pure abstraction (which may be where someone like Jacques Derrida says we must live, so thank God for Helene Cixous).
There was the question Pike often asked some of us about whether we thought IPA (the International Phon-etic Alphabet) was a kind of “emics,” a sort of insider language if used etically to be outside while going in. This is quite technical, I know, and the technicalities and the technical-ness will bring us to Pike’s next pickle; but first this. Pike would do the “monolingual demonstrations” mentioned in 4) above; and he would try to use the language of the other person only. He would actually agree that he was using the other languageS of the other person, because with the actual words spoken, the two—Pike and the one whose language he was learning—would also gesture and assume friendliness between the two (the friendliness an explicit “set up” arranged by a mutual friend so that there’d be no meanness, no sarcasm, no intentional resistance, and so forth). And yet, Pike also used IPA to record all he heard, and he’d use an English gloss, and he’d map out sounds on a grid mirroring the points of articulation within the mouth, and he’d map out morphophonemic contrasts, and he’d map out grammar contrasts, and he’d map out syntax. Then the two language speakers would debrief in English for the sake of the larger audience. So Pike used his various languages. And because he did, he could not completely—purely—move from his own “outsider” (or etic) position towards the other’s own “insider” (or emic) position. Rather, and this was his pickle, his etics were often (or perhaps always? he would ask us) just more emics. For anyone who has yet to learn IPA, for instance, is really in the etic position for that “etic alphabet” but becomes an insider using an “emic alphabet” once IPA was learned. So Pike mused, rightly, about intermediary stages of insiderness and outsiderness, and whether the whole notion of emic and etic really turns, again, on where one stands.
There was the question about whether tagmemics would be adopted across disciplines and live on. Pike really wanted the theory to be understood and used as a meta-theory (or as Joe Kissell calls it “the linguistic theory of everything”). He did not want it to be deconstructed or deconstructable as a metanarrative must be (although he seems to allow for that when writing on page 7 of Linguistic Concepts: “All theories eventually are doomed to be outmoded.”) The “Tagmemics” seminar I was in with him only had two of us who were linguists; the others, all hand picked, were experts or professionals in different disciplines and were women and men of various races. And much earlier, Pike had already been writing for publication in the fields of rhetoric and composition. Within linguistics, his wife, his sister, and some of his friends had begun to apply tagmemics in various directions. Thus, this was not just a theory for linguistics, for translation, and particularly for Bible translation. But unfortunately, I hear that in the Bible translation organizations in which Pike worked, tagmemics in not in vogue. Moreover, it’s all but abandoned in composition and rhetoric (and I’ve written some about this as I started into comp/rhet as an outsider).
Into the Wild at the Kitchen Table
The rules of this game:
Pick up the nearest book of 123 pages or more.
(No cheating!) Find Page 123.
Find the first 5 sentences.
Post the next 3 sentences.
Tag 5 people.
Fire up the MacBook Pro in the kitchen this morning and, reading the rules of this game, fumble around in the dark for the nearest book. Flip on the light switch. It's my daughter Amelia's Lost Star: The Story of Amelia Earhart by Patricia Lauber. 106 pages. Next book. It's the one Amelia gave me for Christmas, that my wife's now reading. (Why I won't cheat, I don't know. Not even tempted here in the quiet.)
More and more of the classes he took addressed such pressing social issues as racism and world hunger and inequities in the distribution of wealth. But despite his aversion to money and conspicuous consumption, Chris's political leanings could not be described as liberal.
Indeed, he delighted in ridiculing the policies of the Democratic Party and was a vocal admirer of Ronald Reagan.
Into the Wild, by Jon Krakauer
From this kitchen table in Texas, once the wild wild West, I tag Billie, Deborah, Hugo, Lily, Philip.